Real Estate Information Header

Much Ado About Mansionization?


Is there a perpetual shadow hovering over your house? Do you feel as though you live in a Batman movie? You may be the victim of a neighboring McMansion or a new development trend called mansionization, the housing industry's equivalent to bigger portions and fast food.

These mansionizers-who are frequently "spec" builders--buy small or dilapidated homes, raze them and erect massive structures, often resembling sterile apartment buildings. Except for meager set-backs, they swallow up the entire lot, dwarf their Liliputian neighbors and invade the privacy of adjacent yards with their second-story windows. It's sort of like jamming five hotels onto "Baltic Avenue" and calling them a home. There simply isn't enough space without impacting the "Community Chest" and monopolizing the other players in the game.

Most U.S. building codes are "mansionization friendly." For example, Beverly Hills caps home size at 15,000 square feet, restrictive only for those who dream of adding the ever-popular indoor football field.

Los Angeles allows a 7600 square foot home on a 5000 square foot lot. This isn't fuzzy math, and the city is not saying you should re-position your neighbor's fence in the middle of the night, gaining a 2600 foot advantage for your new breakfast nook. You must build towards the sun, potentially leaving your neighbors in the dark.

McMansions are perceived by some as the answer for a "Supersize Me," SUV society that subscribes to the notion that bigger is better and that all of ones extended family-regardless of whether they are still alive-must fit neatly into ones abode, even though there are an average of only 2.5 inhabits per property in the U.S.

Proponents of these mini-castles say they increase the value of neighboring homes, help with much-needed living accommodations and are inevitable. As urban and suburban space becomes scarce, McMansions will pop up in much the same way as "more compressed" Europe is dotted with row houses.

The average size of U.S. homes has grown over the past 45 years from 1,140 to 2,225 square feet, according to a Harvard University study. The National Association of Home Builders reports that 21 percent of houses built in 2004 equaled or exceeded 3000 square feet.

These statistics boost the "inevitability" argument. The "increase in property values" assertion succeeds or fails depending on various factors, such as where ones house is situated, the nature of the community and what type of buyers are looking for homes at the time. Are they gourmets or gourmands? Do they welcome McMansions or are they afraid of monsters?

The last argument by McMansionites seems flawed. It is unclear how a gargantuan property accommodating two or three inhabitants, as statistics indicate, aids the ever-increasing demand for housing. Mansionization's "contribution" seems more likely to reinforce the image of America as a land of over-consumption and spotlight the gap between the rich and middle class.

Outraged neighbors in California, Connecticut, Illinois, Pennsylvania, New Jersey, Maryland and Massachusetts convene with local officials to discuss how to halt these stucco intruders, their goal being to implement moratoriums and anti-mansionization ordinances.

Their arguments typically hinge both on objective and subjective factors. In addition to problems associated with a loss of privacy and sunlight, many seek to retain the character and architectural tone of their neighborhoods. They argue that the "David and Goliath" disparities and lack of pleasing curves on many of these "architecturally challenged" monstrosities make their communities less aesthetically appealing. Criticism of the "boxy" look is all too common.. But what if some people--such as McMansion shoppers--cherish the boxy look?

Should government dictate taste, ruling whether a structure is a fairy princess, a plain Jane or an ugly stepmother? Are Building and Safety employees-usually ex-contractors-experts on charm and color coordination? Will art school graduates have to take their place? New ordinances could force homeowners to hire "housing stylists," in much the same way as Cher and Cameron Diaz employ wardrobe aides and makeup artists.

Do we want to forfeit individuality, self-determination and the freedom to do as we please with our single family dwellings, all in exchange for neighborhood uniformity? After all, architectural consistency-as well as Big Brother-can be found in the condo complex or gated community. CC&Rs can impose fines on those who paint their doors red, have garage sales or allow their over-eating poodle to breach the "doggie weight limit."

Local government must resist the temptation to formulate aesthetically-based rules; however, this does not preclude activist neighbors from boycotting certain builders and educating buyers about the merits associated with rejecting "trophy houses" comprised of cheesy materials. McMansion supply hinges on McMansion demand.

Many builders construct quality products with style, grace and concern for residents of the area. They must be encouraged while less considerate developers should be brought into dialogue with local council members and the stakeholders in the community.

In the end, it's not a matter of "much ado, " but a matter of much to do.

Charlotte Laws, Ph.D. is a member of the Greater Valley Glen Council, a Realtor with Prudential in Studio City and an author. Her real estate website is http://www.YourTopBroker.com and her political website is http://www.CharlotteLaws.org

Her blog for comments about this article is http://charlottelaws.typepad.com


MORE RESOURCES:

CORRECTING and REPLACING The Inland Real Estate Group of Companies ...
MarketWatch - 5 hours ago
ANNOUNCES ACQUISITIONS DURING FIRST HALF 2008 TOTALING NEARLY $1.7 BILLION The Inland Real Estate Group of Companies, Inc. today announced that the ...
Sunrise Real Estate Group, Inc. Will Restate the Previous ... MSN Money
all 12 news articles


Fitch Ratings Affirms Gramercy Real Estate CDO 2005-1
MarketWatch - 6 hours ago
Gramercy 2005-1 is a revolving commercial real estate (CRE) cash flow collateralized debt obligation (CDO) that closed on July 14, 2005. ...


Van Meter Real Estate pays $1.8M for Cool Springs office condo
Bizjournals.com, NC - 8 hours ago
Van Meter Real Estate has purchased an 8095-square-foot office condo for $1.8 million in the newly developed Carothers Park in Cool Springs. ...


Tampa Bay Crown Jewel "Bella Sol" Condominiums to Sell at Real ...
MarketWatch - 9 hours ago
JP King Auction Company, the nation's leading real estate auction marketing firm specializing in high-value properties, is managing the sale. ...


The Risks of Real Estate
Motley Fool - 11 hours ago
But every now and then, I'll run into someone who's just as excited about real estate. It can be hard to argue with someone who's realized significant gains ...


Boston Globe

Real estate and recession are taking a toll, but strong capital is ...
Twin Cities Finance and Commerce, MN - 2 hours ago
And the rapid rise in delinquent loans is a hint that more longtime borrowers may still be done in by a damaged real estate industry, flat economy and ...
AM Best Special Report: More Bank Failures Expected As Real Estate ... MarketWatch
Dear FDIC: I Want a Better Mortgage, Too Motley Fool
all 353 news articles


Real estate slide continues in July
Aspen Times, CO - 4 hours ago
GARFIELD COUNTY — The real estate market continued to slide last month in Garfield County compared to the year before. Sales in July tumbled 57 percent ...


Alabama Power picks Leigh Davis to head real estate department
The Birmingham News - al.com, AL - 5 hours ago
Alabama Power Co. said its chief information officer, Leigh Davis, has been picked to lead its department that manages the utility's real estate needs. ...
Alabama Power names new department head Montgomery Advertiser
all 2 news articles


Voice of America

More McCain Real Estate Porn
The Plank on TNR.com, DC - 7 hours ago
The following January, John Rhodes, the iconic Phoenix representative, decided to retire. The looming primary would determine his successor in such a ...
L.A. Land: Readers wish that John McCain could remember how many ... Los Angeles Times
Democrats Dropped Big Hints on McCain Houses Wall Street Journal Blogs
McCain, heiress wife worth almost $100 million Canada.com
Newsweek - National Post
all 758 news articles


Neighbor: Lakeside man shot real estate agent over condo dispute
San Diego Union Tribune, United States - 1 hour ago
By Ray Huard EL CAJON – A Lakeside man shot his real estate agent twice in the head – killing him on the spot – in a dispute over competing offers for a ...

Real-Estate - Google News

General Real Estate Information HomeHome ContactContact
Real Estate Information © 2006